Man made diamonds vs real - Shilat

Man made diamonds vs real what to expect

The Man made diamonds industry has long marketed the allure and prestige of “real” mined diamonds...

The diamond industry has long marketed the allure and prestige of “real” mined diamonds by emphasizing their billion-year underground origins and perceived scarcity compared to “fake” simulated stones. This messaging portrays cultured diamonds grown above ground through technological processes as inferior imitations threatening the value of diamonds formed naturally below the earth over eons through heat and pressure. However, scientific evidence now verifies laboratory-grown diamonds have essentially equivalent physical, optical and chemical properties to their mined counterparts. They test identically across all quality benchmarks like cut, color, clarity and carat. As consumer awareness grows around these facts, marketing language seeks to reframe the difference as “real” versus “man-made” diamonds to preserve notions of innate hierarchy. But does this distinction hold up to intellectual scrutiny, or serve to justify inflated pricing for rare natural diamonds at a time when production innovations allow expanding access to identical crystals once restricted to wealthy elites?

Mined diamonds crystallize slowly over billions of years as carbon particles deposited to the earth’s mantle get compressed under extreme heat and pressure kilometers below the crust. In contrast, lab diamonds use specialized equipment to meticulously simulate those temperature, pressure and environmental conditions to grow lavish diamond crystals above ground in just weeks or months. This accelerated process replicates natural diamond origins, yielding gems with essentially equivalent brilliance and chemical structures. Their equal composition remains simply carbon atoms arranged into perfect tetrahedron crystalline formations. So despite taking days rather hours than eons, the output diamonds prove scientifically indistinguishable from their ancient geological counterparts on a molecular level.

diamond dealerOf course no human endeavor fully replicates complex natural processes at work across deep time. But just as cultured pearls mirror the allure of found pearls born inside oysters at the bottom of the sea, technology now verifies recreating diamonds with identical integrity in the laboratory. Classifying them as merely “man-made” risks perpetuating misleading value judgements that ration diamond accessibility based on flawed assumptions and socially-instilled perceptions around authentic origins rather than truths upheld under modern analytics.

Mined diamonds retain unique emotional appeal around perceived genesis rarity and authenticity for those prioritizing luxury status symbols or high-profile investing. For the rest aiming to secure beauty, ethics and affordability when symbolizing their commitments, lab diamonds present a compelling risk-free alternative free from environmental and controversy baggage haunting the traditional diamond supply chain. Shoppers gain flexibility choosing between equivalent rocks born worlds apart – either over 4 billion years underground, or 4 months in high-tech growth chamber. Yet their sparkle looks identical since both remain crystallized elemental carbon at heart.

Comparing the Properties: Natural Diamonds vs Man Made Diamonds

loose diamond Introduction As lab-grown diamond technology advances, the market is poised for immense growth. The global lab-grown diamonds market size was $1.9 billion in 2020 and is predicted to expand at an astonishing 22.7% compound annual growth rate from 2021-2028. Lab diamonds boast identical composition and structure to scarce natural diamonds, but with eco-friendly abundance. This article examines key similarities and differences between the diamond origins.

What Are Lab Diamonds?

Man made diamonds have the same chemical and crystal makeup as natural diamonds [2], making them optically and chemically indistinguishable when cut to the same standards [3]. While natural diamonds form from intense heat and pressure over billions of years underground, lab diamonds are grown by simulating these extreme conditions in a controlled above-ground facility [4].

round brilliant diamond

Production Methods

The two main methods of lab diamond growth are:

  1. High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) - mimicking below-earth temperature and pressure [3]
  2. Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) depositing carbon vapors onto a diamond seed crystal [4]

 

Durability and Hardness Parity with Natural Diamonds

vvs1 lab grown princess diamond

Identical carbon composition and crystalline structures means equivalent durability ratings, including a perfect 10 on the industry-standard Mohs Scale [2]. This makes lab diamonds optimally resilient for jewelry settings and other applications without compromising on toughness or worry of chips, cracks or scratches forming over time.

Optical Performance

Well-cut, colorless lab diamonds exhibit the same exceptional sparkle and brilliance as natural diamonds [3]. Precise cutting and polishing enables optimal internal light reflection and refractive dispersion of spectral colors - the dazzling “fire” diamonds are coveted for.


Skyrocketing Production Volumes

While natural diamond formation relies on sporadic volcanic delivery over eons, lab production volumes are rapidly scaling. The global lab-grown diamond market is expected to reach 20.5 million carats annually by 2026 - a prolific 22.6% growth rate from 2021 [2].


loose lab brilliant diamondAdvancements in Lab Diamond Quality

Initially, lower color and clarity rankings separated lab diamonds from top-tier natural diamond grades. However, 100% of lab diamonds now reach colorless to near colorless rankings with exceptional clarity thanks to optimized growth processes [3]. This minimizes visible differences to the naked eye while maximizing sparkle potential.

Environmental and Ethical Advantages

Lab diamonds offer a more sustainable, ethical alternative to mining [4]. Land destruction, pollutants, and questionable working conditions plague mining. Whereas, lab diamonds emit negligible environmental impacts or ethical concerns [4]. The ability to deliver optically perfect diamonds in labs eliminates reliance on scarce precious resources formed over 3 billion years ago.


Evolving Consumer Perceptions

engagement round diamond ringConsumer views on lab diamonds are shifting positive as shoppers prioritize factors like eco-standards, accessibility, and affordability. Lab diamonds dispel the secrecy or exclusion surrounding the jewelry industry. While mined diamonds retain prestige as exceptionally rare natural treasures, lab diamonds welcome a broader audience to partake in diamond’s brilliance through competitive pricing. Ultimately, aligning personal values with the chosen diamond’s origin often steers purchase decisions.

Lab-grown and natural diamonds share virtually identical mineral properties and diamond characteristics. But their vastly different origins impart distinct narratives. Natural diamonds offer awe-inspiring rarity and magic. Lab diamonds supply ethical abundance without aesthetic compromises. When choosing between the two, individual shopper priorities around sustainability, ethics and pricing guide decisions.

Meta Description: Contrast lab-grown and natural diamonds across shared properties like composition, durability, optics as well as divergent creation narratives, eco-impacts and pricing to understand how these diamond categories compare.

 

Sources :

[1] https://diamondrensu.com/blogs/lab-grown-diamonds/the-impact-of-lab-grown-diamonds-on-the-resale-market

[2] https://www.ourosjewels.com/blogs/topic/lab-grown-vs-real-diamonds

[3] https://belrosediamonds.com/blog/difference-between-natural-and-lab-grown-diamonds

[4] https://www.patersondiamonds.com.au/blog/2024/01/22/lab-diamonds-vs-natural-diamonds

Back to blog